Skip Navigation

Deep Fryers vs. Dutch Ovens vs. Frying Pans

When you want to fry food, there are a variety of different methods and appliances you can use. Youcan use a specialized appliance for deep frying, or create different kinds of fried dishes in a Dutch oven or frying pan. Each technique has unique advantages, so compare them and to find out which one is best for your favorite recipes.

Deep Fryers

Dutch Oven

Frying Pans

Portion Size

Medium to large Small to medium Small

Time Needed

Less MediumMore

Ease of Use

SimpleDifficultDifficult

Deep Fryers

Advantages of Deep Fryers

  • Easy to use - Deep fryers submerge ingredients in oil and cook them evenly on all sides at once.This means you just have to remove the basket when your food is done, and you won't need to flip food to get even cooking.
  • Temperature control - Electronic controls and temperature readouts ensure you can easily monitor and change the temperature.
  • Less oil absorption - The ability to reach and regulate higher oil temperatures will keep your food from absorbing as much oil at low temperatures.

Limitations of Deep Fryers

  • Additional maintenance and cleaning - It will take longer to clean the multiple parts on a deep fryer, and you'll have to be careful of the delicate heating element and other electronic parts.
  • Low versatility - Deep fryers are great at their job, but are typically only capable of a singular use and can't handle other cooking processes.

Browse all deep fryers


Dutch Ovens

Advantages of Dutch Ovens

  • Good for large batches - Dutch ovens can typically hold a lot of ingredients, so you can fry up a larger batch size all at once, depending on your recipe
  • Versatile cookware - A Dutch oven is a reliable piece of cookware that can handle all kinds of different tasks from soup to pasta and sauces, as well as being durable enough for frying.

Limitations of Dutch Ovens

  • Greater variation in temperature - Since you're working on the stovetop, you'll need an oil thermometer to monitor the temperature, and it will be harder to keep the temperature even as you add and remove ingredients.
  • Cleaning - Cast-iron Dutch ovens need to be seasoned in order to perform properly. This means they can't be placed in the dishwasher and will need special care during hand washing.
Browse all Dutch ovens

Frying Pans

Advantages of Frying Pans

  • Less oil needed - Since you're only immersing food in a small amount of oil, you'll use much less oil with this method.
  • Good for small batches - If you're only making enough food for one or two people, a frying pan is an easy way to cook up small portions.
Limitations of Frying Pans
 
  • More oil absorption - Since it is difficult to keep the oil at higher temperatures, more oil will soak into the food.
  • Difficult temperature regulation - It can be harder to keep the thin layer of oil at a steady temperature.
  • More attention needed - You'll have to monitor and regularly turn food to get it evenly cooked on both sides.
Browse all frying pans