Eyes Reviews

Enhance your eyes with either a smoky eyeshadow for nighttime or neutral colors for daytime. Sears offers reviews on eye makeup ranging from a variety of eyeshadows to eyeliners and mascara to eye creams. Whether you're looking for reviews on anti-wrinkle creams for those laugh-lines or the right type of eye pencil liner, Sears has reviews on top-rated eye makeup. Browse Sears eye makeup reviews today.

Sort by

e.l.f. Cosmetics Baked Eyeshadow Baked Brown 0.14 fl oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Jordana Easyliner Retractable Eye Liner Pencil Black .01 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

4 Reviews
4 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(3)
4stars
(1)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Omiera Labs Revimour Eyelash Enhancer Eyelash Growth Serum Eyelash Conditioner by Omiera Labs 0.27 fl. oz. (8 ml)

from Omiera Labs

Overall, others give this:

5 Reviews
5 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(4)
4stars
(1)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

e.l.f. Cosmetics Studio Hydrating Under Eye Primer Transparent 0.35 fl oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Elf HD Under Eye Concealer Setting Powder with Brush Sheer 0.04 Oz.

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Eylure Katy Perry Lashes, Sweetie Pie, 1 pair

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

e.l.f. Cosmetics Shadow Lock Eyelid Primer Sheer 0.11 fl oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

3 Reviews
2 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(3)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Elf Studio Eye Refresh Dark Circles Puffiness ELF Makeup Clear Salon Tools 0.38 Oz.

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Telebrands As Seen On TV Rabbit TV

from Cheapfever

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

VOLUM' EXPRESS® THE COLOSSAL Classic Black Washable Mascara 0.31 FL OZ BLISTER CARD

from salefolks

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

ZINK COLOR bare mineral pigment eye shadow JUNGLE

from Zink Color

Overall, others give this:

2 Reviews
2 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(2)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyelid Primer Pearl 0.17 Ounce

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Maybelline New York Blackest Black Waterproof Mascara 0.22 OZ BLISTER CARD

from The Online Drugstore

Overall, others give this:

2 Reviews
1 Reviewers (50.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(2)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Revlon CustomEyes Mascara, Blackest Black 001, 0.19 oz (5.6 ml)

from TFSbeauty

Overall, others give this:

2 Reviews
2 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(2)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Omiera Labs Illumizone - Dark Circle Cream Under Eye Treatment Anti-Aging Serum by Omiera Labs 0.5 fl. oz.

from Omiera Labs

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

L.A. Colors Premium 12 Color Eyeshadow Palette Poppin Purple 0.28 fl oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Jordana Baked Eye shadow Sand Dumes BE 0.11 Oz 3.0 g

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Radiance NY Drop Dead Gorgeous Lashes Eyelash Growth Serum

from Overstock.com

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Yes to! Age Refresh Eye Firming Treatment, 0.5 fl oz (15 ml)

from healthdesigns

Overall, others give this:

9 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(7)
4stars
(2)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Radiance New York TMPE705 Time Machine Pro-X Eye Lift. Skin Caviar & Syn-Ake Venom Anti-Aging Cream.

from UnbeatableSale.com, Inc.

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Clarins Men Anti-Fatigue Eye Serum by Clarins for Men - 0.7 oz Serum

from Nitro Gadget

Overall, others give this:

4 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(3)
4stars
(1)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Mascara Max Volume Plus .27 fl oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Clarins Double Fix Mascara (Waterproofing Seal Lashes & Eyebrows) by Clarins - 7739580302

from Agritura US LLC

Overall, others give this:

8 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(8)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Elf Eyebrow Kit, Medium 81302, 0.123 oz (3.5 g)

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

901 Reviews
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(600)
4stars
(208)
3stars
(58)
2stars
(24)
1stars
(11)

Jordana Best Lash Extreme Volumizing Mascara Black .3 fl oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

5 Reviews
4 Reviewers (80.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(3)
4stars
(1)
3stars
(1)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

e.l.f. Cosmetics Smudge Pot - Long Lasting Eye Shadow and Eye Liner 0.19 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

4 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(3)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(1)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

e.l.f. Cosmetics Smudge Pot - Long Lasting Eye Shadow and Eye Liner Cruisin Chic 0.19 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

4 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(3)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(1)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Elf Cream Eyeliner, Black 81160, 0.17 oz (4.7 g)

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1522 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(904)
4stars
(371)
3stars
(131)
2stars
(78)
1stars
(38)

Elf Cream Eyeliner, Coffee 81159, 0.17 oz (4.7 g)

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1521 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(903)
4stars
(371)
3stars
(131)
2stars
(78)
1stars
(38)

Elf Essentials Shimmer Eyeliner Pencil Black 2 fl oz 1 Pc

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

380 Reviews
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(189)
4stars
(135)
3stars
(40)
2stars
(13)
1stars
(3)

Yes to! Soothing Eye Gel, Sensitive Skin, 1.01 fl oz (30 ml)

from shopGourmet.com

Overall, others give this:

63 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(37)
4stars
(16)
3stars
(4)
2stars
(2)
1stars
(4)

L'Oreal Studio Secrets Professional Eye Shadow, Color Smokes, Blackened Smokes 936, 0.16 oz (4.8 g)

from oh!Dreamy

Overall, others give this:

26 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(19)
4stars
(4)
3stars
(1)
2stars
(2)
1stars
(0)

Olay Regenerist Anti-Aging Roller, Daily Treatment, Eye, 0.2 fl oz (6 ml)

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

25 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(19)
4stars
(5)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(1)

Garnier Light/Medium Sheer Tint Anti-Dark Circle Eye Roller 0.5 FL OZ BOX

from Perfumeworldwide

Overall, others give this:

70 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(46)
4stars
(10)
3stars
(6)
2stars
(2)
1stars
(6)

L'Oreal Matte Shadow Duo 0.08 OZ PLASTIC COMPACT

from TFSbeauty

Overall, others give this:

13 Reviews
4 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(9)
4stars
(4)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Olay Age Defying Eye Gel, Classic, 0.5 oz (14 g)

from Perfumeworldwide

Overall, others give this:

32 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(26)
4stars
(2)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(4)
1stars
(0)

e.l.f. Cosmetics Smudge Pot - Long Lasting Eye Shadow and Eye Liner Aint That Sweet 0.19 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

4 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(3)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(1)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Elf Flawless Eye Shadow Tantalizing Taupe 0.21 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

101 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(47)
4stars
(32)
3stars
(10)
2stars
(8)
1stars
(4)

Elf Flawless Eye Shadow Smoky 0.21 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

101 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(47)
4stars
(32)
3stars
(10)
2stars
(8)
1stars
(4)

Jordana Fabuliner Liquid Eyeliner 0.054 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(0)
4stars
(1)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Elf Studio Eyeliner & Shadow Stick, Smoke/Black 81102, 1 stick

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

436 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(151)
4stars
(166)
3stars
(65)
2stars
(45)
1stars
(9)

Elf Flawless Eye Shadow Party Purple 0.21 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

102 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(47)
4stars
(32)
3stars
(11)
2stars
(8)
1stars
(4)

Elf Flawless Eye Shadow Golden Goddess 0.21 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

101 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(47)
4stars
(32)
3stars
(10)
2stars
(8)
1stars
(4)

loreaL Black 200 Silkissime Eyeliner 0.03 OZ PEG

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

1 Review
1 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(0)
4stars
(1)
3stars
(0)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

Elf Flawless Eye Shadow Happy Hour 0.21 oz

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

104 Reviews
1 Reviewers (50.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(49)
4stars
(33)
3stars
(10)
2stars
(8)
1stars
(4)

Eylure Katy Perry Lashes, Cool Kitty, 1 pair

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

2 Reviews
2 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(1)
4stars
(0)
3stars
(1)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(0)

L'Oreal Magnetic Metallic Shadow Duo PLASTIC CONTAINER

from TFSbeauty

Overall, others give this:

35 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(19)
4stars
(11)
3stars
(1)
2stars
(0)
1stars
(4)

Elf Lash Kit, Natural 1713, 1 kit

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

150 Reviews
4 Reviewers (100.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(67)
4stars
(51)
3stars
(19)
2stars
(10)
1stars
(3)

Elf Studio Mascara, Lengthening & Volumizing, Waterproof, Black 81801, 0.24 oz (7g)

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

155 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(77)
4stars
(36)
3stars
(19)
2stars
(19)
1stars
(4)

Elf Lash Kit, Dramatic 1714, 1 kit

from Kmart

Overall, others give this:

76 Reviews
0 Reviewers (0.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
(39)
4stars
(23)
3stars
(3)
2stars
(7)
1stars
(4)
Items   1-50  of 500+
Next >
close x