Related Stories

Overall, others give this:

161 Reviews Write a review
118 Reviewers (73.0%) would recommend this to a friend.
Overall Rating Breakdown:
5stars
4stars
3stars
2stars
1stars

Reviewers may have received a benefit, like a sweepstakes entry or rewards program points, in exchange for writing a review.
Those benefits were not conditioned on the positive or negative content of the review.

Most Helpful Reviews

Praise6 found this helpful
MHouseMcCoy
Apr 4 , 2013
INCREDIBLE PATIO SET
We bought this patio set the summer of 2012 for our 13'X14' covered patio. This set comes with all necessary parts to easily assemble (about 1.5 hr assembly time). Very sturdy and comfy as well! We get compliments all the time from our guests. Very durable, as we leave it outside year round through all the elements; and not a sign of wear has been detected. The cushions come with removable foam, so you can unzip the cushion covers, throw them in the washer/dryer, and everything's perfect. Great, great buy and a must have for those looking for dark wicker/rattan/resin pation furniture.
Criticism11 found this helpful
Boudainlover
Apr 17 , 2013
Forget About This One!
I have had this set for 1 1/2 years. It is now tearing apart. It has been under a covered canopy and still ripped up. I paid full price for this and expected it to last more than a little over a year for the money I paid. I'm highly upset. Contacted Sears they will not allow the return because its over 90 days. Sears told me to contact the manufacturer, but will not give the info. I will have to search Ty Pennington's company on my own.....and i will! It's a pathetic piece of junk. Do not waste your money here, a bad deal! Oh yeah, it has damaged our new concrete patio due to the rust or whatever that is draining. Leaves orange rings on concrete.
 
Jul 18 , 2014
Overall
I love my set

I order this on line with out seeing. I purchase and receive on the time. easy to put together the quality is very good and looks great. The set are comfortable and I love on my patio.

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review
Jun 12 , 2014
Overall
Loved it at first - rusting after less than a year

Gorgeous set that we really enjoyed. We keep it covered every night with a water proof cover. After a few months it started showing orange rust water running down the legs and onto our deck - stained the deck. Any humid or wet days and it has rusty water leaking from it. Contacting the manufacurer direct in hopes they have a solution or will offer a replacement. Disappointed!


Helpful
(3)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

KansasQueen

Arma, KS

May 30 , 2014
Overall
Love this set!

I received this set as a mother's day gift last year and it looked great! I took special care in keeping the cushions DRY and covered and we stored it out of the elements for the winter. We just set it back up to enjoy for this season when our home was struck by a tornado! This set took a beating and came out with only minor damage due to debris piercing it! I was impressed with the strength of the glass in the table, because I lost every window (about 20) on that side of the home and the glass was intact. I am replacing this set with the exact one! The cushions do get a stinky musty mildew smell if they get wet, so keep them dry.

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

LuvFun1

Frisco, TX

May 9 , 2014
Overall
Ty Pennington Style Mayfield 4 Pc Deep Seating set

This set took a long time to put together. The cushions faded within a couple months. This is the second summer and the cushions all need replaced. They have torn from normal use and did not hold up very well. The base seating set did but the cushions were horrible and they don't sell replacements sets. For a $800+ set and now buying replacement cushions...frustrating.


Helpful
(5)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

Jemun4

Huntsville, AL

Apr 11 , 2014
Overall
Fabric will mildew within a year -RUN

We are so disappointed with the fabrics - after being in a protected screened-porch for a year, most cushions are mildewed. I am now scouring the Internet for cleaning idea...never again will I buy cushions other than Sunbrella. you get what you pay for. I just pray I can fix these cushions....


Helpful
(10)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

Markg3126

Pylesville, MD

Apr 3 , 2014
Overall
very nice

We have had this set for over 2 years Really nice, get lots of good comments. Very Happy. We do not keep furniture out year round.


Helpful
(2)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

gbgolfnut

Livermore, CA

Mar 27 , 2014
Overall
Do not buy

We bought all the pieces of this set in thenSpring of 2012 & were very pleased at first. Those feelings didn't last long. We covered everything when it rained & stored it all during the winter. The fabric molds easily & is hard to clean, then there's the problem of the cushions shredding which happens just past the 1 year warranty. This isn't cheap patio furniture but I wouldn't buy it again & definitely wouldn't recommend it. Sears doesn't care to stand behind their products.


Helpful
(5)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

cjbj

Fallbrook, CA

Feb 7 , 2014
Overall
DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY

Nice looking comfy set but...... the cushions fall apart in one season. Literally rot apart even keeping them covered with 'good' quality covers. And then, try and find new cushions that fit... Because they are oversized and deep no one has them and IF you do find them on line they will cost a lot more than the whole set originally cost. If you buy ANY patio furniture, measure the cushions and see if they are a standard size befor buying. This is apparently common in a number of stores not just Sears.


Helpful
(7)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

scubadiver89

Mobile, AL

Jan 26 , 2014
Overall
love it!

awesome set ..easy to keep clean. excellent quality

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(1)
Flag this Review

natgemmi

Wolcott, CT

Dec 28 , 2013
Overall
Great set

This is a beautiful set. Looks elegant and is comfortable to sit in. The assembly was also easy as the set comes with all the tools you need! The construction is very high quality and worth the cost. The cushions are reversable which gives you a different look. The look is very inviting!!!

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(3)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

somewher

Lawrence, KS

Oct 20 , 2013
Overall
Does not last at all

Have this set for 1 1/2 year. It is falling apart. The wicker material on the seats breaks left and right and the 2 chairs are useless already. All furniture was stored inside in the winter, but that did not make a difference. DO NOT BUY! Nice looking set but terrible quality.


Helpful
(6)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

edthecat

Lake Ozark, MO

Sep 28 , 2013
Overall
Mildew!

Bought this set 1 1/2 years ago and noticed a few black spots this June on a couple of the pillows, now I have mildew on all the cushions and pillows and this set has never been out in the elements. It's on a screened and roofed porch. Of course Sears does not back this product so they gave me the number of the vendor. Nothing but a busy signal there. It is appalling that these cushions are not mildew-proof.


Helpful
(5)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

CapeCodSummer

Arlington, VA

Sep 26 , 2013
Overall
Mildew after two months!

The cushions are covered in mildew and the cleaning instructions say no bleach. It's a nice set if you're not near the ocean.


Helpful
(3)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review
Sep 18 , 2013
Overall
mayfield deep seating set

absolutely beautiful. I'm so happy we bought it.

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(1)
Flag this Review

Boathouse57

Tyler, TX

Sep 12 , 2013
Overall
Patio Furniture

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(1)
Not Helpful
(1)
Flag this Review

Shelldor

Sherrard, IL

Sep 5 , 2013
Overall
solid good looking

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

Dunks27

Greencastle, PA

Aug 25 , 2013
Overall
Great buy!

Very impressed by this set! It is solid, well-built and has some weight to it, which is what we wanted. It's deep seated and is very comfortable, but we're thinking of getting the ottomans just to add a little more comfort. You have to put together everything, but it only took a couple of hours if one person is working on it. Even the packaging was impressive- every piece had the corners wrapped and everything was strapped and secured properly. I would definitely recommend this set for indoor or outdoor seating-- worth the money!!

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

kstevens100

Suwanee, GA

Aug 24 , 2013
Overall
Cushions mildewed

This set says it has all weather cushions. I have this exact set in my screen room. The cushions mildewed. The owners manual care guide says "no bleach". Soap and water didn't work. So now what? The set is 15 months old.


Helpful
(3)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

Lfj88

Freehold, NJ

Aug 24 , 2013
Overall
Beautiful set!

Really nice quality and very comfortable

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

TBelue

Cullman, AL

Aug 13 , 2013
Overall
Mayfield collection

I purchased the Mayfield Deep Seating Collection, as well as, the 7 piece dining set in March 2013. I love the furniture itself, however, all cushions have mildew on the striped side. Very disappointing as all furniture is on a completely covered porch and never get wet. Also, noticed all pieces are made in China. :(


Helpful
(2)
Not Helpful
(1)
Flag this Review

Iamtiredofthis

Sault Sainte Marie, MI

Aug 8 , 2013
Overall
Beautiful and Most Comfortable

Prior to buying this set - I sat in it for about 20 minutes. Sometimes after a few minutes the cushions deflate and it becomes uncomfortable. Not this set - it is soooo comfy.

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review
Aug 2 , 2013
Overall
Perfect

The set looks quite nice in my new outdoor room and the price was great for a 4 piece set.


Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

HarpyrraInCM

Costa Mesa, CA

Aug 1 , 2013
Overall
Super Comfy

Inspired to get this set when patio stuff started to go on sale at deeper discounts. Had a bit of a struggle locating a set still in box at the time (apparently pretty popular) ended up contacting 3 stores to locate. Definitely a 2 person job to load and unload and bring a truck, container will never fit in anything less than a full-size SUV with the seats down. Very well packed for shipment (almost too well, will take half your construction time to unpack). Once out of the box all the pieces go together in less than 2 hours. So far cushions and covers seem well made and we've entertained on them a couple of times and friends seem impressed as well.

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

AC.Beach.Bum

Ventnor City, NJ

Jul 30 , 2013
Overall
Ty Pennington Mayfield furniture - score!

I'd give this furniture a 5 but need to see how it holds up in the Jersey salt air. Love it, got two 4 pc. sets and 1 xtra side table and will probably get another set or some rocking chairs. I'd say it looks as good as the pictures. If you're thinking about it I'd say get it. Assembly required.

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(0)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review

Singapura

Westborough, MA

Jul 30 , 2013
Overall
Comfortable & Quality Construction

I am very picky and took some time to select this set. It is beautiful. Not difficult to assemble if you have basic do-it-yourself skills, took my husband and I about 2 hrs to unpack and assemble. Solid construction and quality in the details, like rounded arms where your hands are (much more comfortable than square arms) and lined underneath the arms with the same woven wicker as rest of furniture. Deep seated and very comfortable. Cushions are quality constructed too and water resistant, meaning you take them in at night or when it is raining. Perhaps those giving negative comments on this point left the cushions outside rain or shine because it is called "outdoor furniture"? If you take reasonable care, this furniture will look great and last for years.

I would recommend this product to a friend.

Helpful
(1)
Not Helpful
(0)
Flag this Review
close x